Monday ∗ 03 Jun 2013

Vice Ganda’s false apology

there is no doubt in my mind that joking about the rape of a woman is a no-no, which is like joking that you will kill a faggot. these are black and white, they are premised on gender discrimination, these are violent thoughts we do not think, and do not think to articulate when we actually do think about them out of anger or spite.

and yet i get it, too, that really fantastic comedy, the kind that’s intelligent enough to be irreverent, can talk about rape without it being an attack on women, as it does become an attack on the men who think it correct. Vice Ganda was far from intelligent about this joke, and as such there is no saying that members of the audience “didn’t understand it.”there was no depth here, and please do not even invoke irreverence: that joke about how Jessica Soho would be gang raped, was offensive because it was crass and flimsily premised on her weight. this was no intelligent comedy. this was good ol’ crass comedy, one that is anti-woman. because would Vice Ganda joke about a man’s weight? would he joke about raping a man?

and only the foolish and ill-educated about popular culture and the iconography of Vice Ganda would think this whole brouhaha over that joke to be merely a matter of (mis) (not) understanding what kind of comedy it was:

It wasn’t the politically correct, dry humor — he was going for the loud, outrageous, borderline-if-not-outright slapstick one.

Farces and absurd dramas, by nature, are always politically incorrect; they always deal with extraordinary and larger-than-life characters. Vice Ganda’s performance was never meant to be realist, or to be taken in a realistic set-up. The purpose of that kind of humor is precisely, if not solely, to defy political correctness — and, yes, he succeeded.

where in that video clip did you see slapstick at all? and outrageous? what about some larger-than-life characters? Vice Ganda was Vice Ganda on that stage. and no, there was no indication that she was going for the fantastic, i-am-not-myself, impersonation that say, you would get from the more intelligent comediennes like Willie Nep and Jon Santos. this set up was nothing but realistic, in fact it was stand-up comedy as we know it to happen in this country, in those comedy bars where comediennes make fun of the members of their audience.

where comediennes like Vice Ganda become famous and move on to TV because they are themselves. that is not an act. and this is why it’s even more dangerous.

because Vice Ganda’s iconography has become about Showtime, and it’s become about noontime TV and the kids that watch that. granted that this joke didn’t happen on nationwide television, in the age of phone cameras and youtube uploads, a star of her stature should’ve known better than to think a concert would get anything less than the same mileage.

in fact that this was posted at all as a video clip, is telling of how, while Vice Ganda’s got an audience that will pay to watch her in concert, they will also have the sense to be critical, if not to be offended.

but also it is this notion that we were offended because we just didn’t understand the joke, or because jokes will be acceptable to some, and not to others, that just made things worse for Vice Ganda and this mistake. because this was not a matter of who or how many of us took offense. this was a matter of whether having joked at all about rape was right, given the context in which it was done, the kind of comedy it was within.

and the answer is no. the apology should have been about delivering that message. the apology should have said: i am sorry for having made a joking matter of rape. rape and all other forms of violence should not be used to get some laughs. the apology should have told the young kids watching Vice Ganda on TV every day, that she made a mistake in talking about the rape of woman, and for that she is sorry.

anything less than that, is missing the point. it is also making a mockery out of the task of  apologizing, as it does make fools of us all, falling back as it does on the idea that once you ask for forgiveness, then all should be okay, and the burden is now on those who do not want to accept your apology.

no, the burden is not on us who cannot and will not forgive based on what is a non-apology. the burden is still on Vice Ganda. because she might think herself forgiven, she might have friends and fans who will defend her, but in the long run, there is no denying that here is a comedienne who made fun of a woman, by talking about her rape.

that goes for everyone who thought this joke funny. that includes you, Charo Santos Concio.

ni Ruth Elynia Mabanglo

Ginahasa ako ng mga salita,
Hanggang magutay ang diwa.
Buntis ang alaala
Sa mga alimura,
Pasa-pasa ang puso’t
Lama’y salanta.

Ginahasa ako ng mga akala,
Hanggang pagkatao’y mapariwara.
Pumintog sa puson
Ang haplit ng tinig,
Bitak-bitak ang bungo
Sa madlang hagupit.

Ginahasa ako ng pasya,
Minsan lang,
Minsan lang,
At nagiba ang pag-asa.

Posted in: arts and culture, bayan, entablado, iconography, kalalakihan, kawomenan, komentaryo, pangyayari, star creation

Tagged: , , ,

7 Comments/Pingbacks

  1. hello
    June 3, 2013 at 3:50 pm

    Natanong ko kasi parang hindi niyo nilahad iyong konteksto ng joke. Na what if si jessica ay isang bold star at dapat may scene na gang rape.

    Iba siya sa kung ang joke ay gang-rape-in si Jessica Soho lang.

    Konteksto lang.

    Mas maganda lang na mas malinaw. Kaya kayo napagbibintangan na hindi niyo nagets iyong joke dahil mali rin iyong paglahad niyo.

    Dun lang tayo sa patas na paglalahad.

    Ngayong klaro na pwede niyo nang kastiguhin si Vice Ganda. Wala rin kasing nagsabi kay Vice Ganda na ang mere mention ng rape sa isang joke ay nakapagpapababaw ng karanasan ng mga rape victims at nakakakontribyut to sa konsepto ng rape culture.

    Snark snark kasi muna ang inaatupag wala nang pag-eedukasyon.

    • katrina
      June 3, 2013 at 4:00 pm

      so kung ang usapin ay bold star si jessica soho, hindi offensive yon?

      kung ang usapin ay bold star na mataba si jessica soho, hindi offensive yon?

      kung ang usapin ay bold star si jessica soho na may re-rape-in siya sa pelikula, hindi offensive yon?

      layer upon layer naman ng offense ito hindi ba? ang paghusga at pagkastigo sa isang tao dahil sa itsura niya, dahil babae siya, ang paggamit sa isang tao para sa katatawanan at ihagis rito ang naratibo ng panggagahasa, ay offensive to begin with and by default.

      at teka sino bang dapat nagae-educate? hindi si vice ganda ang may responsibilidad na ganyan? dahil siya mismo ang kumikita sa pagpapatawa at pagiging totoo sa tv.

      snarky? may sa-snarky pa ba sa ginawa ni vice ganda?

    • Dm
      June 3, 2013 at 5:06 pm

      What an outrageous comment. Pinanood ko po ang buong video nitong Vice Ganda ninyo, at kahit halos hindi mo matapos dahil sa kabastusan ay pinilit ko para makita yung sinasabi ninyong konteksto. Sa huli ay ganoon pa rin ang nakatatak sa aking isipan. Itong komedyante kunong ito ay dapat idemanda at ikulong dahil sa kalapastanganan niya sa isang nilalang, babae man siya o lalaki, sikat man o hindi.

    • mauro
      June 4, 2013 at 5:33 pm

      the ultimate test, would you like your children/pamangkins to grow up with the brain of jessica or that of vice ganda?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© Katrina Stuart Santiago  ·  Contact Me
Wordpress theme and web development by @joelsantiago